Breed Perspective

One Breed, Many Purposes Rethinking the Field and Show Divide

PhotoFC AFC Wight's Behind The Eight Ball QA2, Molly (left), and BISS CH Dickendall Buckstone Deck The Halls MH, Decker (right). Molly courtesy of Tracy Wight; Decker © Elizabeth Arellano Photography.

The Labrador Retriever Club has long carried a reputation for the rift between the field Labrador and the show Labrador, a divide hotly contested by their people and talked about as though the two were nearly different breeds. After more than sixty years in this breed, with top show dogs that have gone on to prove themselves in other venues, I have never found the two camps to be the rivals they are so often made out to be. We are all working toward the same goal in different ways. We want to preserve the qualities that make the Labrador Retriever such a remarkable, versatile breed.


The show exhibitors want to preserve the whole dog. Conformation, the frame and the way a dog is put together, and soundness are equally as important as the classic type, the head, the coat, and the otter tail. And all of it matters just as much as the temperament and the retrieving ability. The field trialers have a very different aim that has developed into a look all its own. Their dogs have tremendous drive, speed, and heart, and they work in close partnership on complex tasks with real precision. It is an extreme sport, one only the most talented dogs and handlers can compete in. These are exceptional competitors, and the training, time, and work that goes into them is total dedication. Our show dogs still possess a natural retrieving instinct. They are lower key than the field trial counterparts, but they make super hunting dogs. Field trials call for a different style and temperament, but these dogs are all still Labrador Retrievers.

PhotoTwo directions, one breed: a field-bred Labrador and classic show-type, MBISS CH Dickendall Arnold. Field dog © Elizabeth Arellano Photography; Arnold courtesy of Kendall Herr.

My first dog when I got married was a Labrador Retriever, as my husband was a hunter. I fell in love with the breed after owning it for five minutes, as that friendly, biddable, easy to live with dog really impressed me.

Through the years we have bred and run some of our show dogs in hunt tests and have done well. Our Ruffy, CH Dickendall Ruffy SH, was one of the early AKC Champions to also carry a Senior Hunter title. Ruffy's son CH Topform's Edward, MH was the first bench Champion to be both a Master Hunter and All-Age Qualified in the field, and he went on to produce more of the same. Decker, BISS CH Dickendall Buckstone Deck The Halls MH, was the 50th Champion Master Hunter in the breed and even won a Best in Specialty Show from the hunting retriever class. More recently, Decker's son George, CH Banbury Dickendall Miss Me Now SH, earned his Championship and Senior Hunter as well. Ruffy, Decker, and George all sit on the Labrador Retriever Club's own Labradors of Distinction list, the parent club's roll of dogs that hold a conformation Championship alongside a serious working title. It is their way of honoring the dogs that do more.

PhotoCH Dickendall Ruffy SH at home, and with his trainer Bobby George after earning his Senior Hunter title. Courtesy of Kendall Herr.

The pedigrees tell the same story. MBISS CH Dickendall Arnold, Ruffy's son, was one of the breed's all time top producers, with more than a hundred champions to his credit, but to my mind his real legacy is the versatility and the strong, healthy dogs he left behind. His kids were not only beautiful and sound, they were talented. AKC has recorded over 170 titled get. Nearly fifty dogs were titled in hunt tests, some Qualified at the Master National, dozens earned obedience titles including an OTCH, others titled in agility, and still others became guide dogs for the blind, service dogs, and even police dogs. He was truly a remarkable dog, with a line of great dogs that lives on today, a true hallmark of what this breed can do. Above all, Arnold was my favorite dog, with a temperament that made everyone fall in love with him and that shined through in his kids and grandkids.

That versatility is the heart of what makes the Labrador so special. To the hunter, he's a gundog. To the show breeder, he's classic type that fits the standard. To the field trialer, an extreme athlete that marks and retrieves at great distances with tremendous speed. To the obedience competitor, a teammate. To the service handler, a lifeline. To the family with young children, a best friend. Every one of them is certain the breed belongs to them. And they are all right. No other breed is so versatile, fits so easily into so many lives, and does each job with the same willing heart.

PhotoA Dickendall show-bred puppy with a natural retrieve. © Elizabeth Arellano Photography.

Many of our show dogs can do well in hunt tests, though plenty of breeders and exhibitors are not interested, or do not have the time, the talent, or the help to train for it. The puppies we breed often go on to hunt with their owners too. They are natural retrievers, some of them amazing, the kind of dog that spends a lifetime in the blind retrieving countless birds and making priceless memories, and then settles at its owner's feet when the day is done.

That all said, I will not pretend the show dog and the field dog are the same animal anymore. The field trial dogs have gone in a more specialized direction, where natural retrievers have been elevated into elite athletes, while our show dogs have held to the classic, versatile Labrador. The two have separated far enough that no dog has carried both a conformation Championship and a Field Championship in over fifty years. But the dogs drifting apart does not mean their people have. We can appreciate the greatness of each other's very different sports, and the passion behind them both.

The dogs drifting apart does not mean their people have.
PhotoLeft: A field trial bred Labrador launching for a retrieve, owned by Sciobahn Jones and Right: "Decker, BISS CH Dickendall Buckstone Deck The Halls MH: the standard in motion, demonstrating classic type while getting the job done. Form and function. © Elizabeth Arellano Photography.
PhotoTracy Wight and Molly, FC AFC Wight's Behind The Eight Ball QA2, at the 2023 National Amateur Retriever Championship. Courtesy of Tracy Wight.

More recently we have had the privilege of getting to know the people whose whole world is field trials, and it has been one of the real joys of these last few years. We have celebrated their wins, cheered them on as they ran, watched their dogs work, and seen first hand the dedication this sport demands. Their dogs are athletes of the highest order. Our close neighbor Tracy Wight is a perfect example. She runs FC AFC Wight's Behind The Eight Ball QA2, Molly, a two time finalist at the National Amateur Retriever Championship in 2023 and 2026, and Molly's young daughter Nyx, Wight's Fear the Dark QA2.

What Tracy has built is a huge accomplishment. She bred Molly herself, an FC AFC out of multiple generations of FC AFC champion and hunt test titled bitches. She owns the stud dog behind her most recent litter as well, FC AFC Wight's The Dark Side, Vader. Six of those pups qualified for the 2025 National Derby Championship, and four of them ran. Three, Rev, Stella, and Nyx, were finalists, and the fourth, Boss, reached the eighth series. Every one of them ran with style and great marking ability. She trains and handles her own dogs as an amateur, which makes all of it that much more remarkable. We have been fortunate to help Tracy with some of her breedings to Vader, and through her we have met and made so many field trial friends who pour everything they have into this sport. What strikes me most is not how different their world is from ours, but how familiar the feeling is. The same love of the breed, the same pride in a dog that gives its whole heart, the same long drives and quiet hopes pinned on a promising young dog. They are fueled by the same obsession we have on our side, the one that keeps us up at night trying to breed the perfect Labrador.

What strikes me most is not how different their world is from ours, but how familiar the feeling is.

Every responsible breeder, field or show, wants the same thing, a healthy dog. We run the necessary clearances the parent club requires for CHIC, OFA hips, elbows, eyes, and genetic testing, to keep our Labradors sound for the generations to come. That shared work is one more reminder that we are after the same goals.

For all the ways the show dog and the field dog have split, there is one thing none of us can compromise. We have to protect the temperament that defines this breed, the kind, biddable, steady, sensible, and loving nature that lets them excel in any task. We can differ on type, on coat, on drive, on what we ask of a dog in competition, but that disposition is the soul of the Labrador, and without it we are no longer truly breeding Labradors.

The Labrador Retriever Club, and the fancy as a whole, is a place where we can all work together to feature the greatness of our breed, rather than argue over it. We are not divided by some unbridgeable rift. We are united by a single, simple love for the Labrador Retriever. Whether your dog is running a mark 200+ yards away, hunting the early morning marsh, giving its all in the show ring for a meatball, helping as a life-saving service dog, or asleep at your feet at the end of the day, it is the same wonderful Labrador Retriever we've all fallen in love with.

We are united by a single, simple love for the Labrador Retriever.

· · ·

One Breed, Many Purposes Rethinking the Field and Show Divide

By Kendall Herr, Dickendall Labradors. Photography © Elizabeth Arellano Photography, with images courtesy of Kendall Herr and Tracy Wight.

© 2026 Dickendall Labradors. All rights reserved. This article, including its text and photographs, may not be reproduced, distributed, or republished in part or in whole, in any form or medium, without the explicit written permission of Dickendall Labradors. Photographs remain the property of their respective copyright holders.